LGHS Honors Lemon Grove’s Newest Public Mural: The Lemon Grove Incident


Mark Lane, CEO, Minority Humanitarian Foundation, organized a superb dedication on March 19, 2022 of the new mural on the wall of 7963 Broadway. The artist, Mario Chacon, was present, along with a who’s who of the Mexican American community in Lemon Grove and environs. Organizers had to set up more chairs to accommodate the overflow crowd.

With Lane as emcee, the program opened with artist and Kumeyaay descendant Steven Garcia playing a celebratory solo on a lovely pearwood flute and performing the sacred eagle dance in a spectacular feathered cape and white rabbit fur headdress (see attached video). Amalia Alvarez, granddaughter of the lead plaintiff in the case (Don Roberto Alvarez, Sr.) read a poem she had composed for the occasion. Councilman Jerry Jones, mayor pro tem, spoke briefly and movingly for the City of Lemon Grove.

Yajaira Preciado spoke for the Lemon Grove School Board and several art teachers spoke proudly of their students’ participation in painting thank-yous for the mural. Helen Ofield, board member, spoke for the Lemon Grove Historical Society.

In the crowd were Councilmembers Jennifer Mendoza and George Gastil, former school board member Jay Bass, and Palomar College retired faculty member and cohort descendant John Valdez of Lemon Grove Oral History fame. Dr. Robert Alvarez, Jr., retired UCSD faculty and son of the lead plaintiff in the case (the famous Don Roberto Alvarez, Sr.), gave the keynote address as the. Sr. Mario Chacon wrapped the program with gracious thanks to all and countless photo opportunities.

But the star of the show was diminutive Maria Luisa Beltran Padilla, one of the original cohort of 75 shut-out pupils. She will be 100 in June. Needless to say she was engulfed by a crowd of well wishers. Despite being wheelchair-bound, La Señora Padilla was the last word in charm and enthusiasm.
The mural is stunning. Like the façade of Lane’s building, it focuses on lemons and the people who picked them. The purpose is to render in paint the content of Lemon Grove’s 1931 school desecration case–the first in the nation involving Mexican American pupils.

The case was short, from January 5, 1931 to March 11 when the Writ of Mandamus was handed down by Superior Court Judge Claude Chambers awarding victory to “Los Vecinos” (The Neighbors), meaning the savvy, dedicated parents of the youngsters for whom a bigoted school board  built  a separate, shabby schoolhouse in the “old neighborhood” on Olive Street between Broadway and North Avenue. “Now they won’t have to cross the railroad tracks to get to school” was the feeble rationale.

The segregated school was dubbed “La Caballeriza” (The Barnyard) for its rudimentary appearance. After the big win for attorney Fred Noon and the protesting parents, the school board minutes were a caution:  “Things didn’t go our way, so we’ll go back to what we were doing before.” What they were doing was actually fine. The children were friends, playing together on sports teams and collaborating on class projects. Mrs. Catherine Elliott taught the non English speakers the language for an hour a day with a view to mainstreaming them by grade four. She was the ESL teacher (English as a Second Language) before that phrase entered the language.

So the little city that could, learned the error of its ways and went on to build the most integrated town and school district in San Diego County. It took the whole community pulling together as we saw this morning at the mural dedication. “Sometimes there’s God.”*

*Tennessee Williams’ A Streetcar Named Desire

All Photos by Pedro Bulling


  • Helen Ofield

    Helen M. Ofield is the past president of the Lemon Grove Historical Society. She spearheaded the saving of Lemon Grove’s first church (built 1897) and its adaptive reuse as the Parsonage Museum of Lemon Grove, and the saving of the H. Lee House (built 1928) and its adaptive reuse as the city’s cultural center. Her civic history, Images of America: Lemon Grove (Arcadia 2010) features photographic content by Pete Smith. She is an award-winning writer-producer for national and regional film and television, as well as for print and online news media, a member of the Society of Professional Journalists, former seven-year member of the San Diego County Historic Site Board, and a long-time historic preservationist.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.

New Special Exhibit at the Parsonage Museum: “The Treganza Family Legacy”
HISTORY ALIVE! Just In Time For the Holidays – The Music of John Doan